Here's the 2nd way to get a classic Amy Rose: the Classic Comic 2 Pack. Likely to be $14.99, it's cheaper than the 4 pack (above right) and you only end up re-buying the classic 3.75 Sonic to get her. The issue it comes with is 226 (Archie timeline tie-in story arc) Photo discovered by: Scourger
In summer/fall 2012, Jazwares changed the issue of the comic that is packaged with classic Sonic & Amy. For some reason (Did they run out of that first Genesis arc one?) they've chosen issue 229 , which has (confusingly) modern Super Sonic (note the red eye) as the only character on the cover.
Uh oh, this is an Amy figure with a defect! She's missing her bangs/spikes! This is a photo of her new in the box, in the store...and they just...completely didn't attach that part to the figure. She looks rather odd without it, as illustrated by the correct Amy at the right. Always inspect anything before you buy, if you get the chance. Mistake figures do happen.